Facebook Instagram Twitter
  • Articles
    • News
    • Features
    • Commentary
    • Cartoons
    • Just Married
    • Reviews
      • Read All Reviews
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Restaurants
    • Theatre
    • TV and Streaming
    • Music
  • LGBTQ Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Submit an Event
  • Links
  • Business Partners
  • Subscribe
    • Subscribe to Out In Jersey Magazine
    • Past Issues
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
Search
44.1 F
Trenton
Friday, December 1, 2023
  • About
  • Magazine Issues
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Advertise With Us
Facebook Instagram Twitter
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Out In Jersey - Your LGBTQ Community Portal for Gay NJ Out In Jersey
Out In Jersey - Your LGBTQ Community Portal for Gay NJ Out In Jersey - Your LGBTQ Community Portal for Gay NJ
  • Articles
    • News
    • Features
    • Commentary
    • Cartoons
    • Just Married
    • Reviews
      • Read All Reviews
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Restaurants
    • Theatre
    • TV and Streaming
    • Music
  • LGBTQ Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Submit an Event
  • Links
  • Business Partners
  • Subscribe
    • Subscribe to Out In Jersey Magazine
    • Past Issues
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
Home Articles LGBTQ News Supremes rule LGBTQ civil rights are secondary to the “accommodation” with First...
  • Articles
  • LGBTQ News

Supremes rule LGBTQ civil rights are secondary to the “accommodation” with First Amendment

By
Lisa Keen
-
06/17/2021
1083
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Linkedin
Email
Print
    Rainbow flag waves in Washington D.C. at the U.S. Supreme Court
    Rainbow flag waves in Washington D.C. at the U.S. Supreme Court. Photo by Scott Drake

    Supreme Court disappoints LGBTQ community in Fulton v. Philadelphia stunner

    In a stunning and unanimous judgment, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled Thursday that a city requiring that its contractors obey an ordinance prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation when the contractors claim a religious belief to do so violates the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment.

    The decision is a huge blow to LGBTQ civil rights activists, who just last year won a decision that said “sexual orientation” and “gender identity” are included under a federal law’s prohibition of discrimination based on “sex.”

    Chief Justice John Roberts wrote the June 17 decision and was joined in the judgment by all other justices. Three of the justices—Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, and Neil Gorsuch—filed opinions indicating they agreed in judgment only. The ACLU was quick to point out that, “The court did not, however, establish a general right for religious organizations to violate non-discrimination laws.”

    The oral argument in the case, Fulton v. Philadelphia, went largely unpublicized last November because the nation’s attention was fixated on the outcome of the 2020 presidential election. But statements and questions by some conservative justices during that argument—coupled with the new solid majority of conservatives on the court—left LGBTQ legal activists feeling a bit unnerved.

    In Fulton, the city of Philadelphia discovered that an independent contractor with a contract from the city to provide foster care placement services had a policy of denying such services to same-sex couples. That contractor, Catholic Social Services (CSS), acknowledged its policy violated city law but said no same-sex couple had ever approached the agency so it couldn’t be accused of discrimination.

    When CSS’s contract with the city came up for renewal, the city declined to renew it, saying CSS was in violation of the contract’s stipulation that contractors comply with the city’s laws—including laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of numerous factors, including sexual orientation.

    Chief Justice Roberts wrote that  Catholic Services “seeks only an accommodation that will allow it to continue serving the children of Philadelphia in a manner consistent with its religious beliefs; it does not seek to impose those beliefs on anyone else. The refusal of Philadelphia to contract with CSS for the provision of foster care services unless it agrees to certify same-sex couples as foster parents cannot survive strict scrutiny, and violates the First Amendment.”

    Fulton v. Philadelphia was the latest in a long line of lawsuits that have attempted to secure exemptions for some people and businesses to laws prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity. Those arguing for the exemptions claim that the First Amendment guarantee to free exercise of their religious beliefs should give them the right to discriminate against LGBTQ people.

    Seven of the nine justices are Catholic or have strong ties to the Catholic church.

    © 2021 Keen News Service. All rights reserved.

    • TAGS
    • Catholic Social Services
    • Fulton v. Philadelphia
    • Lisa Keen
    • philadelphia
    • Supreme Court
    Lisa Keen
    https://keennewsservice.com/author/keen/
    Lisa Keen has been reporting news for LGBTQ audiences for over 35 years and is frequently considered the dean of gay political reporting in America. She served as the top editor of one of the nation's most respected gay publications, The Washington Blade, for 18 years.
    Linkedin

    RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

    The Hamburger Mary's cartoon drag queen is on the left holding a hamburger and Ron DeSantis is on the right with a confused look on his face.
    LGBTQ News

    Supreme Court says “No” to Florida drag show ban

    Rainbow flag and is pixelated
    LGBTQ News

    LGBTQ candidate scorecard for 2023 election night

    Philadelphia TikTok influencer Bran Flakezz
    Features

    Bran Flakezz: Philly’s crown jewel of gay chaos and laughter

    The front of the Supreme Court with a Rainbow Flag in the background
    Commentary

    Creep of the Week: Supreme Court

    The exterior of the U.S. Supreme Court.
    LGBTQ News

    The just closed U.S. Supreme Court session — the future is gloomy

    Man waving a rainbow flag at the Supreme Court
    LGBTQ News

    LGBTQ analysis of the 303 Creative decision is mixed

    Support our Business Partners

    Support our Business Partners

    Support the Community

    Support our Community Partners

    Support our Business Partners

    Upcoming events

    Support the Community

    Support our Business Partners

    Out In Jersey Magazine

    737 Hamilton Avenue
    Trenton, NJ 08629

    Phone: 609-213-9310

    Get in touch with us.
    OutInJersey.net

    Facebook Instagram Twitter

    Upcoming Events

    50 Shades Of Gay Holiday Extravaganza at American Legion Post 253 in Spotswood
    50 Shades Of Gay Holiday Extravaganza at American Legion Post 253 in Spotswood
    1 Dec 23
    Spotswood
    Drag Brunch at Six 26 in Jersey City
    Drag Brunch at Six 26 in Jersey City
    2 Dec 23
    Jersey City
    Patrick McDonnell: Community Conversation & Book Signing at Bayard Rustin Center For Social Justice in Princeton
    Patrick McDonnell: Community Conversation & Book Signing at Bayard Rustin Center For Social Justice in Princeton
    2 Dec 23
    Princeton
    Browse More Events

    Pages

    • Homepage
    • Articles
    • Reviews
    • Events
    • Links
    • Partners
    • Subscribe
    • Contact

    About Us

    Out In Jersey magazine covers the interests of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and questioning community of New Jersey.

    • Reviews
    • NJ LGBTQ Events
    • Web Links
    • Business Partners
    • Subscribe
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    © 2023 Out In Jersey | All rights reserved. Site maintained by Jewels Design Works.
    MORE STORIES
    Pope Francis with Transgender logo in the background 2023

    Pope Francis’s community of transwomen

    12/01/2023
    Tally Sessions wearing a brown suit and deer antlers and Priscilla Lopez watching him.

    “The Gardens of Anuncia” is a valentine to one woman’s family

    12/01/2023
    John Travolta wearing a suit jacket and a white button down shirt with the top button undone

    Deep Inside Hollywood: John Travolta

    11/29/2023
    Sam Martino

    What ever happened to civility?

    11/27/2023
    Tom The Turkey over the entrance of Macy's in New York City.

    Creep of the Week: One Million Moms

    11/27/2023
    Transgender symbol graphic

    Asbury Park BOE reaffirms their commitment to trans students

    11/26/2023