Pontiff’s synod is not with the times

Synod Logo 2023
Synod Logo 2023

The Super Bowl of the Catholic Church — General Assembly of the Synod of Bishops, commonly known as the Synod on Synodality — has Rome abuzz. For three weeks, from Oct. 4 – 29, this 4th-century tradition dating back to the beginning of Christianity has brought Catholics from around the world to Rome to discuss a range of topics confronting the present-day Church as it prepares to govern itself in the future.

For a church that moves at the rate of constipation concerning change, transparency, and accountability, this synod gathering is structured to have lots of firsts. It is a pivotal moment, if successful, the Synod will be remembered as Pope Francis’s legacy. Bishops, priests, religious, and lay persons have helped set the agenda for the future, where voting members are not just bishops. Of the 450 members, approximately 378 are voting members, and 50 will be women. Women’s ordination, women deacons and priests, LGBTQ inclusion, and ordination of married men are a few non-traditional topics on the docket for discussion.

The pontiff’s opening and welcoming remarks to the general assembly suggest a church on the precipice of change, readying itself for restorative practices by listening to the voices of those often marginalized or excluded.

“The Church: a single harmony made up of many voices and the work of the Holy Spirit. That is how we should think of the Church. Each Christian community, each individual is distinctive, but this distinctiveness must be included in the symphony of the Church, and that symphony is made ‘just right’ by the Spirit,” Pope Francis told a rapt audience. 

On Oct. 3, the eve of the Synod meeting, Pope Francis sent shockwaves throughout the conference in his homily implying an openness to blessing same-sex unions, with caveats stating they are not equivalent to heterosexual marriages and should decided on a case-by-case basis. 

When Francis was asked by several of his cardinals to clarify his position on the matter in relation to Church doctrine, Francis unequivocally stated, “We cannot be judges who only deny, reject, and exclude.”

While many will contest the explicit double standard in the pontiff’s treatment on the matter, it has nonetheless left many LGBTQ Catholics hopeful. The views are countering the Vatican policy — Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith — that flat-out stated in 2021 the Church couldn’t bless same-sex unions because “God cannot bless sin.”

“While we continue to believe that legal and sacramental marriage equality is the goal, Pope Francis’s statement that there may be ways for the Church to bless same-sex couples is an unexpected and welcome sign of openness,” said Marianne Duddy-Burke, Executive Director of DignityUSA, the world’s oldest organization of LGBTQ Catholics, and a member of the Global Network of Rainbow Catholics. “The sacredness and grace in the relationships between people of the same sex, or where one or more partners is transgender, deserve affirmation and support. Hearing the Pope acknowledge this will give hope to many Queer people, as well as to their families and friends who are Catholic.” 

With the theme of communion, during the second week (Oct. 9-12) of the general assembly, tensions rose about how the Church can extend its welcome to LGBTQ parishioners. Due to both anonymity and confidentiality, only those in the closed discussions knew what was said. However, the choruses of leaks from the talks “expressed skepticism toward efforts better to integrate LGBTQ Catholics into the church’s ministries.”

The Catholic Church still excludes the LGBTQ community from officially receiving any sacraments. Since 2015, DignityUSA, headquartered in Boston, has advocated for “sacramental equality” in the Catholic Church. Holy Communion and funeral rites are not offered to LGBTQ parishioners. From 2020 -2023, I thought the Church would change its view. With COVID-19 death rates hitting the LGBTQ community globally as hard as other minority communities worldwide, one would think the Church could put aside its homophobia.

“The Church is open to everyone, but there are laws that regulate life inside the church,” Francis said in August.

“According to the legislation, they cannot partake in (some) sacraments. This does not mean that it is closed. Each person encounters God in their own way inside the Church.”  

On Oct. 13, the synod moved to the theme of “mission,” meaning the role of women in ministry, including the possibility of the ordination of women to the diaconate. 

The polarization we see in society is also reflected in the Church. Pope Francis invited the Church body into what he hoped would begin the process of change, healing, and respecting the inviolable dignity of all people.