Home Reviews Theater “Empire” is a fable about skyscrapers and the people who built them

“Empire” is a fable about skyscrapers and the people who built them

721
The cast of Empire are dancing on stage.
The Company of EMPIRE. (Photo by Matthew Murphy)
The cast are dancing on stage.
The Company of EMPIRE. (Photo by Matthew Murphy)

Gracing the stages of off-Broadway’s New World Stages is Empire, a new musical by Caroline Sherman and Robert Hull. It tells the mostly-true story of the construction of the Empire State Building and shines a light on the motives behind the men and women responsible for its erection. Set mostly in 1929-1930, it stands as a monument and a remembrance of those who reached for the sky — and those who fell trying.

Empire’s story is related by two women separated by time. In 1976, Sylvie Lee (Jessica Ranville) is packing up her house prior to a move and comes across a box of memorabilia of her mother and her father, who had connections to the building of the Empire State. While going through journals, letters, and scrapbooks, Sylvie interacts across time with Frances Belle “Wally” Wolodsky (Kaitlyn Davidson), chief assistant to former New York governor Al Smith (Paul Salvatoriello), and architect Charles Kinney (Albert Guerzon) on the Empire State project.

The project, with the new building to be named for Smith, is announced just prior to the 1929 stock market crash. With backers pulling out, the state and the city are loathe to construct any new tall office buildings when so many are out of work. Wally suggests they put the unemployed men to work constructing the building, and soon a “melting pot” of New Yorkers, including Poles, Italians, and Irishmen, and a contingent of Mohawk steelworkers from Canada, are breaking ground. But the clock is ticking: Smith’s contracts with the city and state specify that the building must be completed 14 months after construction starts.

Smith and Kinney also want the new building to be taller than the recently-completed Chrysler Building just a few blocks away. Kinney keeps redesigning his original plans while Smith attempts to handle the press, city politicians, the backers, the suppliers — and a contingent of Fifth Avenue matrons determined to prevent a skyscraper debasing their beloved enclave. Smith, being an experienced manager, leaves all of the detail work to Wally, taking credit for some of her better ideas.

Combined with the story of building the Empire State are three love stories. The first involves Irish laborer Ethan O’Dowd (J Savage), a new father once again, who longs to be working on the high steel, and his wife Emily (Morgan Cowling), who wants him to work in safety only on the interiors (“Castles in the Sky”). The second is more of a comic battle of the sexes between the down-to-earth macher Wally and the head-in-the-clouds architect Kinney (“Stuck With You”). Finally, there is a budding romance between Polish laborer Joe Pakulski (Devin Cortez) and Rudy Shaw (Kiana Kabeary), a Mohawk woman who disguises herself as a man to work on the project (“Nothing Comes for Free”).

The cast, under the direction of Cady Huffman with choreographer Lorna Ventura, is quite fine, even when some members have multiple roles. Davidson and Ranville stand out, in their respective eras, interacting with each other across time. Davidson is a proto-feminist, foregoing romance and marriage to focus on the goal of getting the building completed on time (“Never Say Never”). Ranville questions the need for such an expensive project in a time where people are starving — and whether it’s worth the human cost, since the father she never knew died from a fall while working on the high steel (“My Story”). Cortez and Kabeary share a soaring duet about their need to feel free in “Touch the Sky”. 

The wild joy of pre-crash 1929 comes through in the jubilant production number “Heyday.”  The laborers get two solid ensemble numbers:  “Precision and Rhythm,” a ballet of steel work with the beauty of a well-oiled machine, and “Lookahee,” a comic chorus filled with stereotypes in which the guys try out all their best pick-up lines on women on the street below.

The Fifth Avenue matrons, led by comic gem Alexandra Frohlinger as Mrs. Janet Arthur, are loopily single-minded in their determination to “Protect What’s Mine.” Two numbers near the end, “We Were Here” and “Empire,” serve to cement some of the show’s main points: the recognition of men and women who worked without expectation of being remembered and the inspiration and hope the project embodies for all those who see it, whether in 1930, 1976, or today.

The show’s weakest points? First, the book could use some tightening. At two and a half hours, the show’s length allows it to squander opportunities to make a stronger impression on its audiences. Next, the sound. Some lyrics came across as mushy and hard to follow, and some lines, especially for the character Sylvie, were so low as to be practically inaudible. Finally, some numbers need to be re-thought. I won’t name specifics here, but some songs could be combined in performance while others could be rewritten into something with more of a punch.

The show’s best parts? Its spotlight on the contributions of the Canadian Mohawk tribe in building both the Empire State Building and the earlier Brooklyn Bridge, and its use of the Mohawk language, especially in the elegiac “A Change of Worlds,” sung by Danny Iktomi Bevins and April Ortiz with the company to start the second act. Its outstanding set, with moving girders, a giant window, and ladders and staircases, designed by Walt Spangler and lit by Jamie Roderick. Its range of period costumes by Tina McCartney and the hair and make-up designs of Ian Joseph. The orchestra, led by Gillian Berkowitz. Keri Safran, the dialect coach who makes the actors’ various accents sound true to life. And, once again, the tremendous cast, direction, and choreography.

Empire is that rare piece, a show for all generations to see and enjoy. While not as flashy as The Wiz, Aladdin, or The Lion King, or as historically precise as Hamilton or Suffs, it is a solid, entertaining, well-crafted show that just misses being great. I would be interested in seeing future productions of Empire with some alterations made.

Empire is presented at Stage 1 of New World Stages, 340 West 50th St., in New York through Sept. 22, 2024. For more information, or to purchase tickets, go to empirethemusical.com.

Allen Neuner
Allen Neuner is Out In Jersey Media's lead theater reviewer, focusing on New Jersey's professional regional theaters, the Bucks County Playhouse in New Hope, Pennsylvania, and Broadway and off-Broadway shows in NYC. Jersey born and raised, Allen went to his first Broadway play in 1957 and has been deliriously in love with live theater ever since. Allen has been accepted into the American Theatre Critics/Journalists Association, a professional organization. He has been partnered to music reviewer Bill Realman Stella, with whom he is also deliriously in love, for over 25 years. They live in an over-cluttered house in Somerville.