• Articles
    • News
    • Features
    • Commentary
    • Cartoons
    • Just Married
  • Reviews
    • Read All Reviews
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Restaurants
    • Theatre
    • TV and Streaming
  • NJ LGBTQ Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Submit an Event
  • Web Links
  • Business Partners
  • Subscribe
    • Subscribe to Out In Jersey Magazine
    • Past Issues
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
Search
34.8 F
Trenton
Thursday, February 2, 2023
  • About
  • Magazine Issues
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Advertise With Us
Sign in
Welcome! Log into your account
Forgot your password? Get help
Privacy Policy
Password recovery
Recover your password
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Out In Jersey - Your LGBTQ Community Portal for Gay NJ Out In Jersey
Out In Jersey - Your LGBTQ Community Portal for Gay NJ Out In Jersey - Your LGBTQ Community Portal for Gay NJ
  • Articles
    • News
    • Features
    • Commentary
    • Cartoons
    • Just Married
  • Reviews
    • Read All Reviews
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Restaurants
    • Theatre
    • TV and Streaming
  • NJ LGBTQ Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Submit an Event
  • Web Links
  • Business Partners
  • Subscribe
    • Subscribe to Out In Jersey Magazine
    • Past Issues
  • Contact
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
Home Articles LGBTQ News Advocates file amicus brief in suit to preserve non-discrimination in child welfare...
  • Articles
  • LGBTQ News

Advocates file amicus brief in suit to preserve non-discrimination in child welfare services

By
Peter Frycki
-
08/24/2020
1305
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Linkedin
Email
Print
    Rainbow circle with family and a child

    The suit seeks to show bias and discrimination in the child welfare system

    The Center for the Study of Social Policy (CSSP) and National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR) along with over two dozen other organizations have filed an amicus brief in the U.S. Supreme Court. The case, Fulton v. City of Philadelphia, involves Philadelphia’s child welfare program, in which the city contracts with private agencies to provide foster care services.

    In recent years the city required all contractors to refrain from discrimination when providing services on behalf of the city. But Catholic Social Services filed suit,  claiming a constitutional right to violate the city’s non-discrimination requirement. CSS is unwilling to certify same-sex couples as potential foster parents when providing services for the city.

    On June 8, 2018, the national ACLU and the ACLU of Pennsylvania filed a motion to intervene in the lawsuit on behalf of the Support Center for Child Advocates, a nonprofit that represents and advocates for children in the foster care system, and Philadelphia Family Pride, a nonprofit membership organization of LGBT people and their families.

    The amicus brief highlights the government’s compelling interests in protecting children and eliminating discrimination in the child welfare system. The government’s interest in preventing discrimination is particularly urgent as research has shown that nationwide, the current child welfare system is plagued by bias and discrimination based on race, national origin, religion, gender, disability, sexual orientation, and gender identity.

    “Any discrimination harms the children the state is charged with protecting and shatters the families the system is charged with preserving,” said Cathy Sakimura, deputy director and family law director at NCLR. “Bias can and does infect the system at any point.”

    The brief notes that families of color, parents who are poor or with low incomes, parents with disabilities, and LGBT parents are far more likely to be investigated. In many cases they have had their children removed from their homes based on bias and negative stereotypes. The religious organizations sometimes cause great harm both to the children and to their families, say LGBT activists.

    Professor Nancy Polikoff has written about a study of black mothers with low incomes. In 2016 she indicated that lesbian or bisexual participants were more than four times likelier than heterosexual participants to have lost their children to the state in child welfare proceedings.

    Non-discrimination requirements are extremely important in the child welfare system because the stakes are so high, the brief explains. Decisions based on bias lead to children being taken away from their families. Many times there is no valid reason to do so except bias. It sometimes leads to children being placed in foster homes where they will encounter discrimination or even abuse, say advocates.

    “Without unbiased decision making, children cannot be guaranteed the care they require to grow into healthy and successful adults—and could, in fact, be placed in homes that create harmful and long-lasting barriers to their health and well-being,” said Bill Bettencourt, CSSP Senior Fellow. “A ruling requiring the City to allow discrimination in its child welfare program would turn the foundational principles of the child welfare system on their head.”

    Fulton v. City of Philadelphia background

    On July 13, 2018, a federal district court denied CSS’s motion for a preliminary injunction and rejected the argument that child welfare agencies have a right to discriminate.

    On July 16, 2018, CSS asked the Third Circuit to enter an emergency injunction granting the relief denied by the district court.  The Third Circuit denied that motion on July 27, 2018.

    On July 31, 2018, CSS asked the U.S. Supreme Court to issue an emergency injunction granting the relief denied by both the District Court and Court of Appeals. On Aug. 30, 2018, the Supreme Court denied their motion.

    On April 22, 2019, the Third Circuit upheld the district court’s ruling denying CSS’s motion for a preliminary injunction.

    On Feb. 24, 2020, the U.S. Supreme Court announced that it has granted cert in the case, meaning that the court will hear arguments in the case in its next term.

    The current court calendar shows the opening arguments will be heard at the Supreme Court one week after election day this November.

    • TAGS
    • aclu
    • Bill Bettencourt
    • Catherine Sakimura
    • Catholic Social Services
    • child welfare
    • courts
    • CSSP
    • LGBT adoption
    • Nancy Polikoff
    • NCLR
    • philadelphia
    • US Supreme Court
    Peter Frycki
    Peter Frycki is the Publisher of Out In Jersey magazine and an occasional writer and reviewer. He enjoys bicycling, long walks, reading non-fiction biography and historical novels. History, politics, and current events are a passion all-day long that keep him very busy.

    RELATED ARTICLESMORE FROM AUTHOR

    Photo of the outside steps of the Supreme Court
    LGBTQ News

    Alliance drops longstanding florist case at the Supreme Court

    Court gavel
    LGBTQ News

    Supreme Court cuts down donor disclosure requirement

    Supreme Court LGBTQ protest file photo
    LGBTQ News

    Understanding Fulton v. Philadelphia: The ‘bullets’ will keep coming 

    Gay dads with their son at a San Francisco Pride parade
    Commentary

    Adopting Church babies: NOT what the Fulton decision is about

    Rainbow flag waves in Washington D.C. at the U.S. Supreme Court
    LGBTQ News

    Supremes rule LGBTQ civil rights are secondary to the “accommodation” with First Amendment

    Editorial Cartoon on Trans rights
    LGBTQ News

    Trans athletes are under attack in 20 states

    Support our Business Partners

    Support our Business Partners

    Support the Community

    Support our Community Partners

    Support our Business Partners

    Upcoming events

    Support the Community

    Support our Business Partners

    Out In Jersey Magazine

    737 Hamilton Avenue
    Trenton, NJ 08629

    Phone: 609-213-9310

    Get in touch with us.
    OutInJersey.net

    Upcoming Events

    Gay Men Of Hoboken & Jersey City Happy Hour at Dear Maud in Hoboken
    Gay Men Of Hoboken & Jersey City Happy Hour at Dear Maud in Hoboken
    2 Feb 23
    Hoboken
    Welcomin' The Community Breakfast at Bayard Rustin Center For Social Justice in Princeton
    Welcomin' The Community Breakfast at Bayard Rustin Center For Social Justice in Princeton
    3 Feb 23
    Princeton
    Meetup With Pride at Ferry Park in North Cape May
    Meetup With Pride at Ferry Park in North Cape May
    3 Feb 23
    North Cape May
    Browse More Events

    Pages

    • Homepage
    • Articles
    • Reviews
    • Events
    • Links
    • Partners
    • Subscribe
    • Contact

    About Us

    Out In Jersey magazine covers the interests of the lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and questioning community of New Jersey.

    • Reviews
    • NJ LGBTQ Events
    • Web Links
    • Business Partners
    • Subscribe
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    © 2023 Out In Jersey | All rights reserved. Site maintained by Jewels Design Works.
    MORE STORIES
    Gov. Ron DeSantis standing in front of the Florida state flag.

    Creep of the Week: Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis

    02/02/2023
    Valentines Day hearts and wine glasses

    Gift Guide: Valentine’s Gay

    02/02/2023
    Sam Martino

    Women continue shattering glass ceilings

    02/01/2023
    Cover of RuPaul's latest album

    New music to kick off 2023

    02/01/2023
    New Jersey graphic rainbow colors with youth graphic

    New Jersey’s sex education argument continues to fester

    02/01/2023
    A man with a brown jacket sitting in the woods

    “The First Fallen” is an emotional and honest tale about the...

    02/01/2023